Feb 2018
19 15 12 08 05 01 
Jan 2018
29 25 22 18 15 11 08 04 02 
Dec 2017
28 21 18 14 11 07 04 
Nov 2017
30 27 23 20 16 13 06 02 
Oct 2017
30 26 23 19 16 12 09 05 02 
Sep 2017
28 25 21 18 
Aug 2017
28 
Sep 2017
20 18 13 11 07 04 
Aug 2017
31 28 24 22 17 14 10 03 
Jul 2017
31 27 24 20 17 13 10 06 03 
Jun 2017
29 26 22 19 14 12 08 06 01 
May 2017
29 25 22 18 15 11 08 04 02 
Apr 2017
27 24 20 18 13 10 06 03 
Mar 2017
30 27 23 20 16 13 09 06 02 
Feb 2017
27 22 20 16 14 09 06 02 
Jan 2017
30 26 23 19 17 16 12 09 05 03 
Dec 2016
27 22 19 15 12 08 05 01 
Nov 2016
28 24 21 17 14 10 07 03 
Oct 2016
27 19 13 06 
Sep 2016
29 20 
Aug 2016
25 
Sep 2016
22 14 08 01 
Aug 2016
26 18 11 04 
Jul 2016
28 21 14 07 
Jun 2016
30 23 16 09 02 
May 2016
26 19 12 05 
Apr 2016
28 21 14 07 
Mar 2016
31 24 17 10 03 
Feb 2016
25 19 18 13 11 04 
Jan 2016
28 21 14 07 
Dec 2015
30 24 17 10 03 
Nov 2015
26 19 12 06 
Oct 2015
30 23 19 16 09 02 
Sep 2015
25 21 
Aug 2015
28 
Sep 2015
10 04 01 
Aug 2015
27 21 14 07 
Jul 2015
31 24 16 10 03 
Jun 2015
26 19 12 05 
May 2015
29 22 15 08 01 
Apr 2015
24 17 10 01 
Mar 2015
27 20 13 10 06 
Feb 2015
27 20 13 06 
Jan 2015
30 28 26 23 16 09 02 
Dec 2014
27 19 12 05 
Nov 2014
28 26 21 14 07 
Oct 2014
31 24 17 10 02 
Sep 2014
26 23 18 
Aug 2014
29 
Sep 2014
19 12 05 
Aug 2014
29 22 15 08 01 
Jul 2014
25 20 18 
Jun 2014
20 13 06 
May 2014
30 23 16 09 02 
Apr 2014
25 18 11 04 
Mar 2014
28 21 14 07 
Feb 2014
28 21 14 07 
Jan 2014
31 24 17 10 03 
Dec 2013
27 20 13 06 
Nov 2013
29 22 15 08 01 
Oct 2013
25 18 11 04 
Sep 2013
27 20 
Aug 2013
31 
Sep 2013
20 13 06 
Aug 2013
30 23 16 09 02 
Jul 2013
26 19 12 05 
Jun 2013
28 21 14 07 
May 2013
31 24 17 10 03 
Apr 2013
26 19 12 05 
Mar 2013
28 22 15 08 04 01 
Feb 2013
22 15 
Aug 2012
31 
Feb 2012
22 
Aug 2011
30 
Feb 2011
22 
Aug 2010
30 
Feb 2010
22 
Aug 2009
30 
Feb 2009
22 
Aug 2008
30 
Feb 2008
22 
Aug 2007
30 
Feb 2007
22 
Aug 2006
30 
FIFA 18 Database has been updated to Feb 19, 2018.
Sorry for the server problems that made so many anonymous squads and shortlists, you could visit https://sofifa.com/squads/anonymous and https://sofifa.com/shortlists/anonymous to get back your squads and shortlists.
Thanks for your support, I will try my best to keep the site working correctly.
Cookies help us improve our web content and deliver a personalized experience. By using this website, you agree to our use of cookies.
Toggle Columns:
Basic
Attacking
Skill
Movement
Power
Mentality
Defending
Goalkeeping
Special
Name
Age
OVA
POT
Team & Contract
Value
Wage
Total
Reset
Loan Date End N/A May 27, 2015 Short Passing 55 58 Team Brentford Milton Keynes Dons Loaned From N/A Brentford
22
63
71
Milton Keynes Dons
May 27, 2015 (Brentford)
€0
€0
1613
2195 Hits
142 Comments
Acceleration 78 79 Agility 77 78 Balance 68 79 Ball Control 64 65 Dribbling 67 70 Finishing 65 68 Loan Date End N/A Jun 30, 2015 Long Shots 58 59 Overall Rating 65 67 Positioning 60 65 Potential 78 80 Reactions 61 66 Short Passing 61 64 Skill Moves 2 3 Sprint Speed 76 77 Strength 51 49 Team FC Bayern Munich Hamburger SV Loaned From N/A FC Bayern Munich Vision 54 57 Volleys 62 67 Weight 60kg 70kg
19
67
80
Hamburger SV
Jun 30, 2015 (FC Bayern Munich)
€0
€0
1617
1187 Hits
318 Comments
17
69
83
FC Porto
2014 ~ 2017
€0
€0
1954
968 Hits
449 Comments
Aggression 71 74 Contract Valid Until 2015 2019 GK Diving 9 8 GK Handling 11 10 GK Kicking 8 7 GK Positioning 15 14 GK Reflexes 14 13 Heading Accuracy 69 74 Interceptions 79 81 International Reputation 2 3 Jumping 80 78 Long Passing 71 73 Long Shots 59 60 Marking 77 80 Overall Rating 75 78 Joined Jan 1, 2009 Jul 30, 2014 Potential 81 82 Reactions 76 77 Short Passing 70 71 Sliding Tackle 76 77 Sprint Speed 66 67 Stamina 74 72 Standing Tackle 77 79 Team Feyenoord Lazio Weak Foot 3 4
22
78
82
Lazio
2014 ~ 2019
€0
€0
1814
642 Hits
611 Comments
Ball Control 84 85 Contract Valid Until 2018 2019 Finishing 56 45 Interceptions 76 78 Long Passing 82 85 Overall Rating 79 80 Short Passing 85 86 Sprint Speed 71 68 Standing Tackle 75 76 Strength 67 56
21
80
86
€0
€0
2093
477 Hits
4535 Comments
Acceleration 79 77 Agility 73 67 Balance 72 63 Finishing 66 64 Heading Accuracy 65 63 Height 181cm 189cm Overall Rating 67 65 Positioning 65 63 Reactions 66 64 Sprint Speed 79 78 Stamina 82 75 Weight 81kg 77kg
18
65
74
River Plate
2013 ~ 2016
€0
€0
1602
304 Hits
372 Comments
Ball Control 89 81 Crossing 65 67 Dribbling 86 85 Overall Rating 77 76 Potential 87 84 Preferred Position 2 LM N/A Reactions 68 69 Strength 58 59
22
76
84
Chelsea
2014 ~ 2020
€0
€0
1936
303 Hits
5784 Comments
Agility 74 72 Contract Valid Until 2017 2019 Finishing 60 64 Joined Jan 1, 2013 Jul 8, 2014 Positioning 64 63 Team Bahia SL Benfica Traits removed Injury Free Volleys 56 61 Weight 72kg 74kg
20
71
77
SL Benfica
2014 ~ 2019
€0
€0
1869
268 Hits
1101 Comments
Agility 66 69 Balance 74 75 Contract Valid Until 2014 2017 Dribbling 64 60 Long Passing 66 61 Overall Rating 65 64 Short Passing 69 71 Sprint Speed 62 61 Stamina 62 63 Strength 52 56
18
64
72
RCD Mallorca
2012 ~ 2017
€0
€0
1574
259 Hits
4179 Comments
Stamina 83 86 Weight 82kg 87kg
22
72
78
Club Brugge KV
2011 ~ 2016
€0
€0
1972
231 Hits
627 Comments
Contract Valid Until 2016 2018 Curve 87 89 Dribbling 97 96 Finishing 97 94 FK Accuracy 86 90 Overall Rating 94 93 Positioning 93 92 Potential 97 95 Reactions 96 94 Shot Power 81 80 Sprint Speed 88 90 Stamina 78 77 Volleys 90 85
27
93
95
FC Barcelona
2004 ~ 2018
€0
€0
2165
227 Hits
28580 Comments
19
57
65
KRC Genk
2014 ~ 2019
€0
€0
1426
215 Hits
1069 Comments
Jumping 48 73 Joined Mar 23, 2008 Aug 18, 2014 Strength 55 61 Team Gimnasia y Esgrima La Plata Racing Club de Avellaneda
24
66
69
€0
€0
1663
207 Hits
127 Comments
Acceleration 72 79 Aggression 55 70 Agility 68 81 Balance 87 90 Ball Control 69 74 Contract Valid Until 2018 2019 Dribbling 68 71 Interceptions 58 71 Jumping 55 56 Long Passing 44 61 Long Shots 34 51 Marking 50 51 Overall Rating 62 67 Joined Nov 18, 2013 Jul 1, 2014 Positioning 48 62 Potential 77 76 Preferred Position 2 CDM RM Preferred Position 3 CAM LM Preferred Position 4 N/A CAM Reactions 69 72 Short Passing 65 67 Shot Power 50 61 Sliding Tackle 62 60 Sprint Speed 75 78 Stamina 91 92 Standing Tackle 64 66 Team FC Istres Ouest Provence FC Red Bull Salzburg Vision 68 57
19
67
76
€0
€0
1815
201 Hits
1980 Comments
Aggression 84 85 Ball Control 87 88 Crossing 74 73 Curve 79 78 Dribbling 85 84 Finishing 71 70 FK Accuracy 69 65 GK Diving 6 5 GK Handling 7 6 GK Kicking 3 2 GK Positioning 5 4 GK Reflexes 4 3 Height 186cm 188cm Interceptions 66 69 International Reputation 2 3 Jumping 81 87 Long Passing 83 82 Long Shots 86 88 Overall Rating 81 83 Penalties 68 67 Positioning 78 77 Potential 90 89 Preferred Position 2 N/A CAM Reactions 79 78 Short Passing 83 82 Shot Power 88 89 Sliding Tackle 85 83 Stamina 84 87 Standing Tackle 81 79 Strength 87 90 Vision 81 83 Volleys 79 78
21
83
89
Juventus
2012 ~ 2016
€0
€0
2217
182 Hits
17938 Comments
Aggression 60 59 Balance 78 79 Ball Control 75 74 Crossing 66 65 Curve 74 73 Dribbling 75 74 Finishing 69 68 FK Accuracy 72 71 GK Diving 9 8 GK Handling 11 10 GK Kicking 9 8 GK Positioning 10 9 GK Reflexes 11 10 Heading Accuracy 63 62 Interceptions 35 34 Long Passing 67 66 Marking 27 26 Penalties 69 68 Positioning 69 68 Potential 84 83 Reactions 63 62 Short Passing 70 69 Shot Power 67 66 Sliding Tackle 36 35 Sprint Speed 81 82 Stamina 71 70 Standing Tackle 34 33 Traits added Finesse Shot Vision 61 60 Volleys 75 74
20
70
83
Palermo
2012 ~ 2016
€0
€0
1836
181 Hits
13039 Comments
Loan Date End N/A May 27, 2015 Team Wigan Athletic Leicester City Loaned From N/A Manchester United
20
69
79
Leicester City
May 27, 2015 (Manchester United)
€0
€0
1755
175 Hits
118 Comments
Agility 73 66 Ball Control 73 74 Contract Valid Until 2017 2019 Dribbling 68 70 Finishing 68 72 Heading Accuracy 59 67 Long Passing 43 52 Overall Rating 68 71 Positioning 69 73 Potential 74 78 Short Passing 66 68 Shot Power 73 74 Stamina 68 70 Strength 63 67
20
71
78
Tottenham Hotspur
2010 ~ 2019
€0
€0
1751
174 Hits
15299 Comments
Balance 75 63 Ball Control 95 92 Dribbling 90 93 Finishing 92 95 Positioning 89 91 Volleys 85 87
29
92
92
Real Madrid CF
2009 ~ 2018
€0
€0
2215
164 Hits
32736 Comments
Acceleration 75 77 Agility 69 76 Attacking Work Rate High Medium Ball Control 74 75 Crossing 63 68 Dribbling 71 75 Finishing 53 63 Interceptions 72 74 Long Shots 62 66 Marking 60 62 Overall Rating 71 73 Positioning 73 74 Reactions 70 72 Sliding Tackle 55 60 Sprint Speed 78 82 Standing Tackle 65 66 Strength 72 67 Traits added Flair, Speed Dribbler Weight 78kg 79kg
19
73
85
FC Schalke 04
2013 ~ 2018
€0
€0
1978
155 Hits
3435 Comments
Ball Control 91 90 Crossing 70 71 Dribbling 92 94 Finishing 84 85 International Reputation 4 5 Long Passing 73 72 Long Shots 69 70 Overall Rating 85 86 Preferred Position 2 CF N/A Preferred Position 3 ST N/A Short Passing 75 72 Vision 74 72
22
86
91
FC Barcelona
2013 ~ 2018
€0
€0
2035
155 Hits
21085 Comments
Acceleration 91 93 Crossing 82 78 Dribbling 90 92 Penalties 85 86 Reactions 84 85 Short Passing 86 87 Stamina 73 74 Traits added Selfish Vision 85 86
23
88
90
Chelsea
2012 ~ 2017
€0
€0
2082
149 Hits
8903 Comments
Agility 73 77 Balance 60 66 Contract Valid Until 2016 2019 Height 185cm 181cm International Reputation 1 2 Joined Jul 12, 2013 Jul 1, 2014 Positioning 85 86 Potential 86 85 Skill Moves 2 3 Sprint Speed 81 80 Stamina 78 77 Strength 74 77 Team Torino Borussia Dortmund Traits added Avoids Using Weaker Foot, Finesse Shot Weak Foot 3 4 Weight 78kg 85kg
24
80
85
Borussia Dortmund
2014 ~ 2019
€0
€0
1902
148 Hits
738 Comments
Acceleration 85 83 Jumping 56 80 Sprint Speed 84 83 Stamina 59 60
23
63
68
FC Dallas
2011 ~ 2016
€0
€0
1619
148 Hits
6 Comments
Acceleration 75 81 Aggression 42 41 Agility 71 80 Balance 73 72 Ball Control 59 70 Birth Date Jun 30, 1995 Jul 30, 1995 Crossing 59 67 Curve 61 67 Dribbling 58 73 Finishing 55 64 FK Accuracy 50 55 Heading Accuracy 44 55 Interceptions 25 52 Jumping 62 61 Long Passing 47 59 Long Shots 62 72 Marking 25 24 Overall Rating 60 70 Penalties 55 57 Positioning 56 68 Potential 63 80 Preferred Foot Left Right Preferred Position 1 RW LW Preferred Position 2 N/A RW Preferred Position 3 N/A RM Preferred Position 4 N/A LM Reactions 54 61 Short Passing 54 67 Shot Power 56 70 Sliding Tackle 25 24 Sprint Speed 78 83 Stamina 53 79 Standing Tackle 27 26 Strength 47 59 Traits added Speed Dribbler Vision 55 60 Volleys 40 73
18
70
80
Pachuca
2014 ~ 2015
€0
€0
1774
147 Hits
2764 Comments
Acceleration 85 87 Aggression 54 53 Balance 76 77 Ball Control 79 80 Contract Valid Until 2017 2018 Curve 72 71 Dribbling 79 82 FK Accuracy 60 59 GK Diving 12 11 GK Handling 8 7 GK Kicking 13 12 GK Positioning 8 7 GK Reflexes 15 14 Heading Accuracy 54 53 Interceptions 36 35 Long Passing 66 65 Overall Rating 75 76 Penalties 60 59 Potential 86 85 Reactions 69 68 Short Passing 68 70 Sliding Tackle 28 27 Sprint Speed 87 89 Stamina 68 75 Standing Tackle 29 28 Strength 74 76 Vision 69 68 Volleys 60 59
19
76
85
Lazio
2013 ~ 2018
€0
€0
1861
146 Hits
1782 Comments
Balance 77 79 Ball Control 82 83 Long Passing 82 81 Preferred Position 2 CM LM Preferred Position 3 LM RM Preferred Position 4 RM N/A Sprint Speed 82 78 Stamina 85 83
23
81
86
VfL Wolfsburg
2014 ~ 2019
€0
€0
2033
143 Hits
7109 Comments
Acceleration 83 85 Ball Control 64 69 Dribbling 62 68 Finishing 64 68 Heading Accuracy 62 65 Overall Rating 63 69 Positioning 59 71 Potential 87 81 Reactions 59 67 Shot Power 66 70 Sprint Speed 85 88 Volleys 41 64
18
69
81
AS Monaco
2013 ~ 2018
€0
€0
1638
138 Hits
10318 Comments
Acceleration 57 65 Agility 65 68 Balance 75 66 Ball Control 58 63 Dribbling 59 62 Height 172cm 184cm Overall Rating 58 60 Potential 72 74 Sprint Speed 62 64 Strength 37 57 Weight 63kg 75kg
18
60
74
FC Schalke 04
2014 ~ 2017
€0
€0
1591
133 Hits
2100 Comments
19
63
78
RB Leipzig
2013 ~ 2015
€0
€0
1756
132 Hits
1963 Comments
Aggression 53 60 Ball Control 73 75 Crossing 71 73 Curve 68 71 Dribbling 74 76 Finishing 56 58 Heading Accuracy 51 56 Interceptions 61 66 Jumping 66 69 Long Passing 76 78 Long Shots 66 70 Marking 48 58 Overall Rating 69 73 Penalties 68 73 Positioning 58 63 Potential 85 88 Reactions 69 73 Short Passing 72 76 Shot Power 63 68 Skill Moves 2 3 Sliding Tackle 56 66 Sprint Speed 69 71 Stamina 68 74 Standing Tackle 58 68 Vision 70 74 Volleys 63 66
17
73
88
RSC Anderlecht
2013 ~ 2016
€0
€0
1982
131 Hits
4598 Comments
Balance 76 75 Jumping 69 68 Potential 83 81
21
76
81
€0
€0
1865
127 Hits
2399 Comments
Acceleration 88 90 Agility 79 78 Ball Control 73 74 Crossing 61 64 Curve 54 58 Finishing 71 70 Long Passing 50 54 Long Shots 62 63 Overall Rating 69 70 Positioning 69 70 Reactions 67 68 Short Passing 68 69 Sprint Speed 89 90 Strength 52 54 Traits added Speed Dribbler
18
70
85
VfB Stuttgart
2013 ~ 2018
€0
€0
1710
127 Hits
1835 Comments
Contract Valid Until 2018 2021
19
65
73
€0
€0
1478
125 Hits
1010 Comments
Acceleration 81 79 Agility 80 84 Balance 63 74 Contract Valid Until 2018 2020 Finishing 78 80 International Reputation 2 4 Long Passing 82 84 Long Shots 81 82 Overall Rating 83 86 Joined Jul 1, 2013 Jul 22, 2014 Potential 89 92 Reactions 84 85 Sprint Speed 78 79 Team AS Monaco Real Madrid CF Vision 86 87 Volleys 77 81 Weight 79kg 75kg
22
86
92
Real Madrid CF
2014 ~ 2020
€0
€0
2114
123 Hits
7228 Comments
Acceleration 81 84 Aggression 32 55 Contract Valid Until 2016 2019 Dribbling 78 80 Finishing 56 62 Jumping 77 70 Long Shots 42 60 Overall Rating 64 71 Positioning 50 58 Potential 78 80 Preferred Position 3 LW ST Reactions 50 68 Short Passing 64 72 Strength 69 71 Traits added Avoids Using Weaker Foot, Flair, Playmaker Vision 63 71
20
71
80
Olympique Lyonnais
2013 ~ 2019
€0
€0
1756
122 Hits
2592 Comments
Acceleration 79 78 Agility 83 84 Ball Control 82 83 Dribbling 86 87 Overall Rating 80 81 Penalties 73 63 Preferred Position 2 RM CF Preferred Position 3 LM N/A Preferred Position 4 ST N/A Short Passing 82 83 Stamina 77 76 Strength 68 72 Vision 80 81 Volleys 72 80
22
81
85
€0
€0
1959
120 Hits
3901 Comments
Acceleration 71 69 Attacking Work Rate Medium High Dribbling 68 71 Finishing 68 71 Long Shots 64 69 Overall Rating 69 70 Preferred Position 1 CDM CM Preferred Position 2 CM CAM Volleys 23 62
21
70
78
Stade Rennais FC
2011 ~ 2017
€0
€0
1831
119 Hits
152 Comments
Balance 66 67 Ball Control 75 76 Crossing 33 36 Curve 29 30 Dribbling 42 55 Finishing 41 43 FK Accuracy 52 54 Interceptions 68 72 Jumping 59 62 Long Passing 72 75 Long Shots 38 49 Overall Rating 71 74 Penalties 48 49 Positioning 45 51 Preferred Position 2 CB RM Preferred Position 3 N/A CB Reactions 70 75 Short Passing 74 82 Shot Power 35 47 Sliding Tackle 70 73 Stamina 68 72 Standing Tackle 73 76 Team Rayo Vallecano Atlético Madrid Vision 62 65 Volleys 28 29
19
74
82
Atlético Madrid
2012 ~ 2018
€0
€0
1771
116 Hits
1519 Comments
Acceleration 90 89 Dribbling 88 87 Preferred Position 2 LM LW Preferred Position 3 N/A CM Sprint Speed 77 75 Traits added Long Shot Taker Weight 72kg 71kg
22
81
86
Liverpool
2013 ~ 2017
€0
€0
1913
116 Hits
8749 Comments
Acceleration 62 63 Aggression 53 54 Ball Control 87 86 Contract Valid Until 2015 2020 Curve 86 88 Heading Accuracy 48 54 Interceptions 65 72 International Reputation 3 4 Long Passing 87 90 Long Shots 90 88 Marking 36 44 Overall Rating 84 85 Joined Jul 1, 2007 Jul 17, 2014 Preferred Position 1 CAM CM Preferred Position 2 CM CDM Preferred Position 3 CDM CAM Reactions 86 87 Short Passing 88 91 Shot Power 88 87 Sliding Tackle 54 59 Sprint Speed 53 54 Stamina 74 75 Standing Tackle 59 63 Strength 68 74 Team FC Bayern Munich Real Madrid CF Vision 86 88 Volleys 83 84
24
85
88
Real Madrid CF
2014 ~ 2020
€0
€0
2136
115 Hits
3564 Comments
Acceleration 72 73 Aggression 55 56 Agility 64 65 Balance 73 74 Ball Control 73 74 Crossing 63 64 Curve 45 46 Dribbling 66 68 Finishing 66 67 FK Accuracy 45 46 Heading Accuracy 42 43 Interceptions 66 68 Jumping 66 67 Long Passing 71 73 Long Shots 53 58 Marking 66 67 Overall Rating 69 72 Penalties 49 50 Positioning 63 65 Potential 75 76 Reactions 68 73 Short Passing 74 76 Shot Power 64 65 Sliding Tackle 57 58 Sprint Speed 74 75 Stamina 74 82 Standing Tackle 68 69 Strength 61 62 Vision 72 74 Volleys 53 54
23
72
76
SM Caen
2013 ~ 2016
€0
€0
1861
110 Hits
5466 Comments
Acceleration 68 72 Aggression 55 54 Ball Control 65 68 Contract Valid Until 2017 2020 Crossing 33 32 Curve 66 65 Dribbling 61 66 Finishing 69 68 FK Accuracy 55 54 GK Diving 13 12 GK Handling 7 6 GK Kicking 12 11 GK Positioning 14 13 GK Reflexes 7 6 Heading Accuracy 67 73 Jumping 64 72 Long Passing 38 37 Long Shots 58 70 Overall Rating 66 68 Penalties 56 55 Positioning 68 67 Potential 76 80 Reactions 62 61 Short Passing 58 63 Shot Power 66 71 Sprint Speed 69 74 Standing Tackle 25 24 Traits added Power Header Vision 49 54 Volleys 59 58
20
68
80
Palermo
2014 ~ 2020
€0
€0
1643
109 Hits
2763 Comments
Height 163cm 170cm Weight 50kg 58kg
18
61
71
SM Caen
2013 ~ 2016
€0
€0
1662
108 Hits
1950 Comments
18
58
67
Chelsea
2012 ~ 2016
€0
€0
1325
106 Hits
1601 Comments
Acceleration 71 69 Agility 70 69 Balance 56 55 Loan Date End N/A Jun 30, 2015 Short Passing 79 81 Sprint Speed 68 67 Strength 60 61 Team Liverpool Málaga CF Loaned From N/A Liverpool Weight 71kg 72kg
21
72
81
Málaga CF
Jun 30, 2015 (Liverpool)
€0
€0
1680
105 Hits
214 Comments
Preferred Position 3 N/A RW Preferred Position 4 N/A ST Stamina 70 68
21
77
84
€0
€0
1868
104 Hits
566 Comments